A network for environmental health and justice

Act with Foresight to Protect Health and Prevent Pollution

Policy paper in support of Plank #6 of the Louisville Charter for Safer Chemicals
Ted Schettler, Steve Taylor | April 2026
Cover of Advancing the Louisville Charter for Safer Chemicals

Contents

Learning From Past Failures To Prevent Harm

Acting On Early Warnings;  Identifying “Credible Evidence” for Protective Action;  When do we know enough to act?

Acting With Foresight: Putting These Principles Into Practice

Create and Strengthen Health and Environmental Programs to Detect and Predict Possible Harm; Consider Clusters of Health Problems to Be Early Warnings; Listen to Affected Workers and Communities; Open Toxic Tort Records; Take Immediate Action when Credible Evidence of Harm Is Found; Supporting Communities to Take Action On the State and Local Level

“Preventing avoidable harm before it occurs is not a radical idea – but in our current chemical management system, it rarely happens,” said Ted Schettler, Science Director of Science and Environmental Health Network and co-author of the paper. “The solutions are not hard to envision. But overcoming corporate influence to implement them will require a united movement committed to protecting the health of current and future generations.”

Chemical policies and practices in the United States – in both government and business – have failed to keep many hazardous chemicals out of widespread use, even after overwhelming evidence of exposure and harm is clear. If examined at all, early signals of toxicity are often ignored or questioned. Against the urging of environmental health and justice organizations, under the 2016 amendments to the Toxic Substances Control Act it remains extremely difficult to restrict production, transportation and use of even the most harmful and most studied chemicals already in commerce.

Louisville Charter for Safer Chemicals plank 6 – Act with Foresight to Protect Health and Prevent Pollution – calls for action to prevent harms. The goal of this background paper is to identify criteria and considerations to guide the timing of protective actions that should be taken to safeguard communities, workers, and others from exposure to a chemical or class of chemicals before serious or irreversible harm has occurred.

Chemical management policies and practices should be transformed at all levels to identify hazards proactively and require quick action to prevent exposures, when credible evidence shows that harm is likely to occur, even when information about the exact nature, scope or distribution of harm is incomplete. New policies and practices are especially needed to protect communities and populations from ongoing harm due to multiple, cumulative, and disproportionate hazardous exposures.

Regulatory agencies should have, or be linked to, programs that can detect / predict possible harm and entities that can report and develop responses to emerging problems. Most importantly, processes should not only be able to gather ‘sufficient information’ but also enable wise and timely decisions. This goes beyond data gathering and warning transmission to encompass decision making that explicitly addresses the needs of the groups and individuals most overburdened by pollution by varying the level of evidence required to take an action based on 1) the nature and distribution of the costs and impacts of being wrong, 2) the current necessity of the chemical in its application, or 3) availability of known safer alternatives.

Frequently asked questions

Related News